Part II – Belonging as Commodity

When migration became machinery, identity was repackaged for performance. This part explores labor, aspiration, and the invisible price of success.

How capitalism turned identity into transaction and migration into machinery.

When the sacred ties of land, lineage, and story were severed, something else moved in to fill the void.
Capitalism, with its machinery of markets and myths of merit, offered a new kind of belonging—one earned
through labor, performance, and productivity.

This part explores how the migration of people became entangled with the migration of meaning. Belonging
was no longer a given—it became something to prove. Cities swelled with those in search of survival or
success. Diasporas emerged not only across geography, but across identity itself. Even in the digital realm, we
began to curate our presence, commodify our culture, and outsource our sense of self to algorithms.

These chapters hold up a mirror to the systems that replaced kinship with credentials, rootedness with rent,
presence with persona. They do not condemn movement—but they ask us to examine who benefits from it,
who is erased by it, and what gets lost in the chase.


Chapter 5: The Dream Machine

When Migration Became Hope Wrapped in Hype

1. The Promise of Elsewhere

Not all movement begins in pain.
Some begins in promise.

Capitalism didn’t just displace people—
it invited them to move.
It built a dream of elsewhere.
A gleaming city. A better life. A fresh start.

And people believed it.
Because sometimes, they had to.

Colonialism had already fractured the old world.
Now, industrial capitalism painted a new one—
with jobs in factories,
streets paved with opportunity,
a future shaped by choice, not fate.

This was the story sold to millions:
Leave the village.
Leave the farm.
Come to the city.
Come to the West.
Come build the life your parents never had.

It sounded like freedom.
And in part, it was.

But this promise—this dream—was not neutral.
It came with conditions.

To belong, you had to produce.
To stay, you had to assimilate.
To succeed, you had to forget just enough of where you came from.

The promise of elsewhere was not simply about hope.
It was about usefulness.
You were welcome—if you served.

The factory didn’t care about your story.
The office didn’t care about your rituals.
The system cared only that you showed up,
on time, every day,
until you disappeared.

This is the dream machine:
Not built to hold your soul,
but to harvest your labor.

And yet—people still came.
Because sometimes a flawed dream
is the only one you’re allowed to have.

2. From Survival to Aspiration

At first, people moved to survive.

War. Famine. Drought.
Colonial extraction left entire regions barren.
People left not because they wanted to—
but because they had no choice.

They became indentured laborers, railroad workers, sugarcane cutters.
They left their homelands in the shadow of empire,
often never to return.

But then the story shifted.

Migration became not only about leaving behind,
but moving toward.
Not just about fleeing hunger,
but about chasing success.

And capitalism knew how to shape that hunger.
It turned survival into aspiration.
It turned need into narrative.

It told the story of the “good immigrant” who works hard,
who pulls themselves up,
who sacrifices for the next generation.
It rewarded those who didn’t look back too much.

So people did what they had to do.
They sent remittances.
They worked two jobs.
They folded ambition into identity.

The village child became the city student.
The farmer’s son became the engineer in Toronto.
The seamstress’s daughter became a nurse in Dubai.

And in every story, there was pride—yes.
But also pressure.

To succeed not just for yourself,
but for everyone who stayed behind.
To prove that migration was worth it.
To carry legacy in a briefcase,
and lineage in your LinkedIn bio.

But this transformation came with a price:
The longing for home became a liability.
Gratitude became silence.
Rest became guilt.

You were not just trying to live better.
You were trying to justify leaving at all.

Because when aspiration is born from dislocation,
you are never quite sure if you’ve made it—
only that you can’t afford to stop.

3. The Myth of the American Dream

Nowhere did the dream machine shine brighter than in America.

The American Dream:
Work hard.
Play by the rules.
And you’ll make it.

Millions crossed oceans and borders to reach this promise.
Ellis Island, green cards, citizenship ceremonies—
each a symbol of belonging by effort.

It was a powerful story.
And for some, it came true.

But myth is not the same as truth.

The American Dream was never equally available.
It was built on land stolen from Native peoples,
built by enslaved Africans,
and protected by laws that excluded, detained, or deported
those who didn’t fit its image.

Chinese immigrants helped build the railroads—
then faced the Chinese Exclusion Act.

Black families fled the South during the Great Migration—
only to face redlining and segregation in the North.
Mexican labor was welcomed during war,
then criminalized during peace.

The dream was real—
but for many, it came with conditions:
Conform.
Assimilate.
Erase.

Hide your accent.
Rename your children.
Swallow your grief.
Be grateful—no matter what.

It was not just about upward mobility.
It was about self-erasure as a prerequisite to belonging.

Still, people clung to the dream.
Because it carried hope.
Because it allowed for dignity—
even if the cost was invisibility.

But the question lingered, quietly:
What is the price of becoming someone else in order to succeed?
And who benefits from that transformation?

Because a dream that demands forgetting—
is not freedom.
It’s performance.

4. When Home Is Not Enough

Long after the move is made—
the visa granted,
the job secured,
the family resettled—
the ache remains.

Not always for the place left behind,
but for the self that once belonged without question.

Because migration doesn’t just move bodies.
It moves identity.

The new city may offer safety,
but you begin to edit yourself to stay safe.
The new job may offer opportunity,
but you learn to suppress parts of you
to be taken seriously.

And soon, you begin to wonder:
Was I running from something?
Or running toward something I was told I should want?

This is the quiet fracture:
When home is no longer enough—
but neither is anywhere else.

You go back and feel like a guest.
You stay and still feel like an outsider.

In diaspora communities, the second generation inherits this ache.
Raised by stories of sacrifice,
haunted by the pressure to make it all worthwhile.
Grateful—yet untethered.
Fluent—yet unsure which tongue to pray in.

They ask, sometimes aloud, sometimes only in silence:
Where is my home?
Is it where I am most accepted?
Or where I am most remembered?

And often,
there is no answer.
Just a longing wrapped in motion.
Just a quiet grief that the dream offered movement—
but not always arrival.

5. Who Gets to Arrive?

Not everyone gets to chase the dream.
Not everyone is allowed to arrive.

While some are welcomed as expats,
others are detained as migrants.
While some are called global citizens,
others are labeled illegal.

The difference often isn’t merit—
it’s origin.

It’s skin.
It’s power.

A tech worker from France gets a visa.
A refugee from Sudan gets a cage.
A student from India is praised for ambition.
A cleaner from Honduras is told to go home.

The dream machine is selective.
It opens its doors to those who serve its needs—
but keeps them shut to those whose survival threatens its image.

And even for those who do arrive,
the dream is tiered.

Citizenship may be earned—
but belonging is still policed.
Your accent.
Your hair.
Your politics.
Your prayers.

You are asked to assimilate,
but never too much.
To succeed,
but never surpass.
To be visible,
but not disruptive.

Arrival, then, is not a finish line.
It is another border.
One you must keep crossing—daily,
in how you speak, work, love, exist.

Because arrival was never just about geography.
It was about permission.

And still—people come.
Not because they believe all the promises,
but because the alternative is worse.
Because sometimes, motion is the only hope left.

But maybe, just maybe,
a new dream is possible.
One that does not require erasure.
One that welcomes without conditions.
One that knows:
to arrive is not to perform.
It is simply to be—seen, safe, and still whole.


Chapter 6: Cities of Displacement

When Belonging Became Rent, and the City Forgot Its Soul

1. The City As Magnet

The city does not promise belonging.
It promises opportunity.

And for many, that is enough.

Because when home offers no safety,
when the land no longer feeds,
when the future back there feels already written—
the city becomes a magnet.

It calls with its lights.
Its factories.
Its anonymity.

You arrive in the city with hope folded into a suitcase.
You come alone, or with kin.
You follow the scent of possibility.

And the city accepts you—
but only in pieces.

You are welcome to work,
to fill its gaps,
to fuel its movement.
But you are not invited to rest.
Not yet.

The city is built for motion.
It rewards hustle.
It normalizes absence—of elders, of quiet, of sky.

It offers everything and nothing at once:
Jobs but no time.
Crowds but no community.
Information but no wisdom.

You find others like you,
also building, also bracing, also bargaining.
Together, you make something resembling a life—
but it never quite becomes a home.

Because the city gathers the displaced,
but does not always know how to hold them.

And slowly, even those who came chasing freedom
begin to feel the weight of something unnamed—
a longing not for return,
but for a kind of presence
the city cannot quite give.

2. Patchwork Belonging

Cities are mosaics.
Built from migration, shaped by collision,
layered with histories both told and hidden.

But not all patches are stitched equally.

Enclaves form—sometimes by choice,
often by force.

There’s a neighborhood where one language dominates.
Where spices drift from balconies.
Where churches and corner stores mimic the home you left behind.

It offers comfort.
It offers survival.
It becomes a second skin.

But often, that skin comes with a border.

“Little” is added to your identity:
Little Haiti. Little Manila. Little Mogadishu.
As if you are not whole—just a flavor,
contained, labeled, tolerated.

The city lets you exist—
as long as you don’t expand too far.
As long as you don’t inconvenience the idea of what the city is supposed to be.

Red lines are drawn.
Zoning laws shift.
Policing intensifies.

Your patch becomes a cage.

And still, people make beauty within it.
Murals. Mosques. Mutual aid.
A resistance that says:
“If we must live in a corner, we will make it sacred.”

But patchwork belonging is not the same as integration.
It is survival architecture—
held together by memory,
by ritual,
by the will to remain visible
in a place that prefers you silent.

The question is not:
Do you have a place in the city?
The question is:
Whose city is it when the lights go out?
And who gets to stay when the rent rises?

3. Labor And The Layered City

Every city has layers.
But not every layer is seen.

There is the city of glass towers and morning espresso.
And beneath it—
the city of kitchens and buses before dawn.

The two cities live together.
But they rarely touch.

One builds wealth.
The other holds it up.

Migrants clean the offices they can’t afford to work in.
They care for children in homes they’ll never own.
They cook the food that others post on menus,
but eat their own lunch in back alleys or shared stairwells.

Their labor is essential—
but their presence is peripheral.

They rise early, move quietly,
disappear when the shift ends.
Rarely seen, unless something goes wrong.
Rarely heard, unless something is demanded.

And still, they carry the weight—
not just of bags and boxes,
but of families back home,
of dreams deferred,
of identities bent to fit job descriptions.

The city depends on them.
But it rarely thanks them.
Rarely protects them.
Rarely pauses to ask:
What would this place be without the ones who arrive first and leave last?

In this layered city,
belonging is not about contribution.
It’s about visibility.
And those who carry the most—
are often seen the least.

But their absence would be felt in a heartbeat.

Because beneath every skyline,
there is a scaffold of invisible hands—
holding everything in place.

4. Dreams Stacked In Rent

The city may offer work—
but it rarely offers rest.

Rent becomes the axis around which everything turns.
A number that decides your neighborhood,
your commute,
your time with your children,
your sense of safety.

For many migrants and working-class families,
the rent is not just high—
it is holy.
Untouchable.
Unquestioned.

You pay it first.
Then you live with what’s left.

Two families in one apartment.
Rotating mattresses.
A curtain instead of a wall.
Parents working double shifts,
not out of ambition,
but necessity.

You get creative.
You adapt.
You endure.

Because to fall behind
is to risk everything.

Landlords do not care about the long journey.
About the cousin still trying to get here.
About the ancestral land sold to fund this move.
They care that the check clears.

And so, dreams become stacked—
not in ambition,
but in square footage.

You don’t dream of luxury.
You dream of a quiet morning.
Of a room to yourself.
Of not choosing between groceries and gas.

This is the quiet violence of the city:
It promises a future,
but charges you your entire present to get there.

And still—
you keep going.
Not because the city loves you,
but because somewhere in its chaos,
you’ve planted the seed of a life.

You water it with sacrifice.
You shield it from eviction.
You believe—because you must—
that one day, it will bloom.

5. Reclaiming Urban Spirit

The city does not belong only to power.
It also belongs to memory.
To music.
To those who build beauty where no one is watching.

Even in displacement,
people make meaning.
They plant gardens in alleyways.
They paint murals on forgotten walls.
They gather for prayer in rented basements,
for weddings in borrowed halls.

In cities built to extract,
they create spaces to exhale.

These are not monuments.
They are moments.
Pop-up temples.
Street festivals.
Sunday cookouts.
Block parties that double as homecomings.

The city can’t always hold them—
but they happen anyway.

Because the spirit of the displaced
is not just to survive.
It is to reimagine.

To turn a street corner into sacred ground.
To reclaim a park as a place of rest.
To sing in a language the city tried to forget.
To build not just community—
but communion.

Some call it resistance.
Some call it resilience.

But maybe it’s just remembering
that even in the most fractured places,
the human spirit finds a way to return.

Not to what was lost—
but to what was possible all along.


Chapter 7: Diaspora and the Hyphen

Living in Between—and Becoming Something New

1. Neither Here Nor There

Diaspora is not just a scattering of people.
It is a scattering of selves.

To live in diaspora
is to wake up in one world
while dreaming in another.

It’s knowing two anthems,
but feeling silence during both.
It’s celebrating holidays
no one else gets off work for.
It’s craving food you’ve never tasted—
because your mother never learned to cook it in this country.

You don’t feel fully at home in the place you live.
And yet, when you return to the place you’re “from,”
you’re a stranger there too.

You’re told you’re not quite American.
But back there, you’re “too American now.”

Diaspora is a geography of longing—
for a place,
for a version of self,
for a wholeness that was broken
before you even arrived.

It is inheritance wrapped in displacement.
You carry your parents’ grief and grit,
even if you don’t fully understand its origin.

You carry their hopes—
sometimes as freedom,
sometimes as pressure.

You belong to two places—
and sometimes to neither.

But in the spaces between,
something else begins to take shape.

Not just loss.
Not just confusion.
But the raw material of something new.

2. The Hyphen As Home

To live between cultures
is to live on a hyphen.

Indian-American.
Nigerian-British.
Palestinian-Canadian.
Hyphenated.
Split.
Stitched.

That small mark holds multitudes—
of memory, of tension, of becoming.

It tries to connect what history once pulled apart.
But it doesn’t always hold.

Some days, the hyphen feels like glue.
A link between worlds,
a reminder you are both—and more.

Other days, it feels like a fault line.
A reminder you’re not fully either.

The hyphen asks you to translate—
from one world to another,
from one language to another,
from one expectation to another.

You become an interpreter.
At school.
At home.
In your own heart.

You know how to switch tones,
how to soften certain truths,
how to code-switch without flinching.

But the cost is real.
Not just exhaustion—
but invisibility.

Because when you are always adapting,
you wonder if you have a self beneath the adjustments.

And still—
the hyphen holds you.

Not because it is perfect.
But because it is yours.

It is not a flaw.
It is a form.
A way of being whole
in a world that prefers to split.

It is not a compromise.
It is a creative act.
A claim:
I come from many places,
and I belong to all of them—
even if none fully claim me in return.

3. Belonging In Translation

In diaspora, language is both a bridge and a bruise.

You grow up speaking one tongue at home,
another at school.
One for love.
One for approval.
One for dreams.
One for documentation.

And somewhere between them,
a third language forms—
not entirely fluent in either,
but enough to navigate both.

You translate for your parents:
at clinics, in job interviews, at the DMV.
You grow up early.
You become the bridge.

But who translates for you?

When your grandmother says something untranslatable—
a phrase wrapped in centuries of soil, grief, and joy—
you smile and nod,
but you know:
a piece of the sacred just passed you by.

This is the ache of second-generation life:
You inherit memory without context.
You feel longing without location.
You carry reverence for things you barely understand.

You may not speak the language fluently,
but you feel it.

In the food.
In the rhythm of your name.
In the stories told half in words, half in eyes.

Belonging in translation is never perfect.
It is awkward. Tender. Sometimes painful.

But it is also powerful.

Because when you choose to learn that lullaby,
to write in your ancestor’s script,
to ask what that proverb really means—
you are not just reclaiming vocabulary.
You are repairing the thread.

You are saying:
This story will not end with me in silence.

4. What Cannot Be Returned To

Every diasporic heart carries the question:
Should I go back?

Back to the village.
Back to the country.
Back to the street in the photograph your parents keep in the kitchen drawer.

But sometimes,
there is no “back.”

Because what you left no longer exists.
Or because it never existed the way you imagined it.

The house has changed.
The language has shifted.
The people you came to see have grown old.
Or grown distant.
Or grown unfamiliar.

You arrive hoping for recognition—
but feel like a tourist in your own bloodline.

Your accent is off.
Your clothes are wrong.
Your questions reveal how much you’ve forgotten.

And still—something in you had needed to come.

To touch the soil.
To breathe the air your ancestors breathed.
To close a loop.

But returning doesn’t always bring relief.
Sometimes it brings grief.

Because it shows you—gently, sometimes painfully—
that home is not a place you return to.
It’s something you carry.
Or rebuild.
Or redefine.

And the myth of return
can be as heavy as the migration that preceded it.

Still, there is beauty in the pilgrimage.
Even when the place has changed,
you haven’t come for perfection.
You’ve come for presence.

And that, too, is a kind of homecoming.

Not to what was.
But to what is.

5. The Gift Of In-Between

For so long, you were told
you were neither this nor that.
Too foreign for here.
Too changed for there.

But what if the truth is—
you are not incomplete.
You are layered.

You are not caught in-between.
You are the in-between.
A place where contradictions can breathe.
Where memory and reinvention coexist.

You’ve learned to see from multiple vantage points.
To hold grief and gratitude in the same sentence.
To speak two languages—
even if one of them is silence.

You understand that identity is not fixed.
It is fluid, migratory, alive.
You belong not in spite of the complexity—
but because of it.

This is the gift of diaspora:
You know how to carry the past
without being crushed by it.
You know how to build forward
without forgetting what was left behind.

You make rituals from memory.
You make culture from fragments.
You make home from intention.

And still, you long.
But longing isn’t weakness.
It’s wisdom.
It’s the compass of those who have traveled far
and still know what is sacred.

So maybe the hyphen isn’t just a bridge.
Maybe it’s a seed.
Planted in rich, complicated soil.
Becoming something new—
not to replace what came before,
but to honor it by evolving.


Chapter 8: Digital Diasporas

Connection Without Contact, Belonging Without Borders

1. The Screen As Homeland

For many in the diaspora,
home isn’t where the heart is—
it’s where the Wi-Fi is strong.

The screen has become sanctuary.
A portal to relatives oceans away.
A window into the language you’re trying not to forget.
A mirror that reflects something familiar—
even when your surroundings don’t.

On the internet, you can find your people.
A WhatsApp group that feels more like home
than the neighborhood you live in.
A meme that speaks in your dialect
and makes you feel seen.
A song you’ve never heard before—
but somehow remember.

Digital space offers what physical space often doesn’t:
Belonging without bureaucracy.
Recognition without judgment.
Community that’s scattered, but alive.

Here, borders blur.
A Tamil in Toronto connects with one in Chennai.
A Palestinian poet goes viral in Spain.
A Zoom call becomes a family reunion,
a language lesson,
a lifeline.

The screen holds what migration disrupted.

And yet,
this new kind of belonging is not without cost.

Because when connection lives on a feed,
and culture is curated through pixels,
we must ask:
Are we truly rooted?
Or just always reaching?

2. Likes, Links, And Longing

To exist online is to be visible.
But in order to be seen,
you must often first perform.

You post the dish your grandmother taught you to make—
with filters, hashtags, and a caption that explains its history.
You share your story of migration—
edited, paced, palatable.
You celebrate your culture—
in a format that fits the feed.

It’s not inauthentic.
But it’s not unfiltered either.

You’ve learned that to gather attention—
and by extension, community—
you must curate.

Because the internet rewards clarity, not complexity.
And diasporic identity is anything but simple.

So you become an online narrator
of your in-between life.

The problem is:
the more you share,
the more you feel exposed.
The more you edit,
the more you wonder what’s been erased.

And still—
you return.

Because the likes feel like affirmation.
The links feel like belonging.
The comments remind you:
Someone out there understands.

But there’s a difference between being seen and being held.
Between being followed and being known.

And beneath the metrics,
a quiet question lingers:
If I stop performing,
will anyone still be here?

This is the paradox of digital belonging—
It connects you across continents,
but can also distance you from yourself.

It creates a village.
But sometimes, that village is watching—
not listening.

3. . The Algorithm As Authority

In the digital diaspora,
the gatekeeper is no longer a government.
It’s an algorithm.

An invisible hand curating your visibility,
ranking your relevance,
deciding whether your voice will echo or vanish.

You could pour your heart into a post—
about language loss,
colonial grief,
diasporic joy—
and it might reach a few hundred.
Or it might go nowhere at all.

Not because it lacked meaning,
but because it lacked momentum.

Meanwhile, a simplified version—
your sari as fashion,
your prayer as trend,
your food as “exotic”—
might go viral.

Because the algorithm doesn’t care about context.
It cares about clicks.

And in this system,
nuance is punished.
Spectacle is rewarded.

The result?
A distorted mirror.

You begin to shape your story not for truth—
but for traction.
You compress your complexity
into what the feed will tolerate.

And in doing so,
something sacred gets negotiated.

Not just your privacy,
but your presence.

You begin to forget
that you’re not here to be content—
you’re here to be whole.

The algorithm is not evil.
But it is indifferent.
And when it becomes the arbiter of identity,
it turns culture into currency.

It turns migration into a brand.
Belonging into a metric.

And it leaves you wondering:
Am I connecting with people—
or just performing for the machine?

4. Virtual Kinship, Real Loneliness

The digital world connects us faster than ever.
Messages cross oceans in seconds.
Voices echo through timelines.
Stories go viral before they’re even finished.

And yet—
we are lonelier than ever.

Because connection is not the same as intimacy.
And being seen is not the same as being safe.

You can have a thousand followers,
but no one to call when grief arrives.
You can belong to ten group chats,
but eat dinner in silence every night.

The screen gives you the illusion of closeness—
but not always the warmth of it.

Especially in diaspora,
where physical kin may be far,
and emotional kin may live only in comment threads.

We call it community.
But sometimes it is just a chorus of monologues.
Everyone speaking.
Few listening.

You scroll through others’ curated lives,
and wonder if your own is too quiet.
You post a memory of home,
and it floats into the feed—
acknowledged, but not necessarily felt.

This is the ache of the digital diaspora:
Presence without touch.
Familiarity without history.
Recognition without relationship.

And still—
we keep returning to the screen.
Not because it fills the absence,
but because it reminds us we are not alone in our longing.

Loneliness shared
becomes a form of kinship, too.

And sometimes,
that is enough to begin.

5. Reclaiming Digital Sacredness

The digital world isn’t inherently hollow.
It holds possibility.
It holds memory.
It holds people who would never have found each other otherwise.

But it must be reclaimed.

Not as a marketplace of performance—
but as a sanctuary of presence.

We can use the internet not just to broadcast,
but to build.
Not just to post,
but to witness.
Not just to scroll,
but to remember.

A ritual can live in a group call.
A blessing can arrive in a voice note.
A story can travel farther now—
without being edited for approval.

Reclaiming digital sacredness is about intention.

It’s about creating space where silence is honored.
Where complexity is allowed.
Where not everything needs to be shared to be sacred.

It’s the Zoom call that begins with a moment of breath.
The livestream that holds grief without rushing to fix it.
The comment section that becomes a digital village—
not because it’s perfect,
but because it’s held with care.

It’s remembering that the ancestors also used the tools of their time:
Drums. Fire. Word of mouth.
We use fiber optics and touchscreens.
But the impulse is the same—
to stay connected,
to be understood,
to carry each other through.

The sacred is not lost in the signal.
It’s in how we choose to show up.
Even here.
Even now.


Share the Spark